Super Smash Bros. director Masahiro Sakurai has shared a number of interesting comments about having originality in games. Related to this, we get some interesting insight into the original launch of Super Smash Bros. This comes via a Denfaminicogamer interview.
Sakurai said that originality is a relatively low priority when it comes to whether a game sells, but it’s still something’s interested in. Without it, “you are better off playing the original.” Sakurai brought up Kirby as an example – it couldn’t just be a side-scroller like Super Mario Bros., so he wanted it to be different.
Despite Sakurai’s interest in originality, he also noted how there can be pushback of sorts when you change something. This may seem obvious, but you expect a Mario game to have the feel of a typical Mario title.
Sakurai also went on to talk about Smash Bros. Had it been your typical fighter, he doesn’t think it would have continued beyond the first game. However, because of its differences at the time, “it was criticized by people who couldn’t get into the differences it had from Street Fighter 2 and Virtua Fighter.”
Our translation of Sakurai’s comments is as follows:
Sakurai: I’ve already spoken about it quite a few times, but ‘creativity’ is quite low on the list of priorities when it comes to whether a game will sell or not. Even so, I still like to personally add something with an element of ‘creativity’ or ‘originality’. Otherwise, if it’s the same thing, you are better off playing the original.
For example, Kirby is also a side-scrolling game, but if it had the same playstyle as Super Mario Bros, then some would say, “Well, you may as well play Super Mario Bros!” Therefore, I think it’s meaningless if we don’t alter the form in some way.
Well, even now this is still a very difficult thing, and I’ve struggled with it for a long time (laughs).
What do you mean by that?
Sakurai: You change something just a little and players think ‘something’s off’. …players ‘expect things to be as they expect them.’ And that’s why they buy them. I expect Mario to have the style of ‘Mario-fun.’
But when you change that as well, it can feel like ‘pretending to be eccentric.’ I think it’s comparable to expecting a certain taste from a food, only to have ‘something different.’ Even if that taste has its own appeal, before noticing that, you’ll feel a sense of aversion.
So saying that, if you make a game without planning for any individuality or new systems, then really ‘it’s better to enjoy the original.’
For example, think about if Smash Bros. had normal fighting game rules. In a 1-on-1 battle, you’d have guard, attack, and special attacks, and once your energy is depleted, you’re KOed and the match is over. I don’t think the original Smash Bros. would have been released like that.
And even if it had been released, I think it would have mostly been seen as a ‘novelty,’ and that would have been the end of the history of Smash Bros.
As for me, I made the game confidently believing that the ingenuity of Smash Bros. and gameplay hooks of elements such as damage accumulation and positioning would be fun. At the time though, it was criticized by people who couldn’t get into the differences it had from Street Fighter 2 and Virtua Fighter. But it’s actually very difficult to ‘intentionally add ingenuity.’ When there are no previous examples, it’s very difficult to explain to staff, and it’s also very important… and difficult… to think about how to aim for and proceed towards what we want.
So you overcome the challenges and make the game, only for it to end with ‘something’s off.’ That’s been the case with some of my own games. Games like Meteos, Kid Icarus: Uprising, Kirby Air Ride, and Air Riders… they’ve all been like that.
Sakurai also spoke about how AI could lead to unoriginal, unplayable games.
Translation provided by SatsumaFS, Philip Proctor, and Simon Griffin on behalf of Nintendo Everything.
Related
Story via Nintendo Everything. Read the original article


































