Banner for GTA 6 Metacritic user scores shown

ⓘ Rockstar Games, Metacritic, Canva AI

Banner for GTA 6 Metacritic user scores shown

As GTA 6 user reviews flood Metacritic, the initial average is surprisingly low. With a large number of 0 scores, a review bombing campaign may be underway. Meanwhile, the Rockstar release earned a 99 Metascore, with critics calling it one of the best games of all time.

Days after the media submitted their GTA 6 Metacritic scores, players are weighing in. While the sales giant notched a record-tying 99 from websites, the user rating currently sits at 5.2/10. Already, signs suggest gamers who don’t own the Xbox or PS5 version are review bombing the title.

A track record of excellence

It’s still early on, so the user score will likely fluctuate. Nevertheless, just hours in, 13,192 scores have accumulated. Older Rockstar candidates like Red Dead Redemption and GTA 4 show a total of 5,000-7,000 ratings. GTA 5 has 17,105 scores, and the more recent Red Dead Redemption 2 has been judged 36,432 times.

The 5.0 GTA 6 Metacritic rating will need a dramatic turnaround to rival those earlier releases. Although GTA: San Andreas has a smaller sample size of 6,517, its 9.1 leads all Rockstar entries. Red Dead Redemption 2 is second at 9.0, with Red Dead Redemption third at 8.9. Lower on the list, GTA 5 and GTA 4 are at 8.5 and 8.4, respectively.

Most games from the studio have earned Metascores of 95 or higher. A divide between critics and players is not unusual, but the gap is much wider with the new Grand Theft Auto. By contrast, the media and fans largely agree on the recent Ocarina of Time remake’s dominance. Rockstar supporters believe naysayers, some of whom didn’t purchase the Xbox or PS5 title, are review bombing.

Lax review requirements

Metacritic unlocked GTA 6 user reviews following a short waiting period once the November 19th release date passed. Unlike the PlayStation Store or Steam, it doesn’t require proof of ownership. Amateur critics only need to register with an email address.

One telltale sign of a campaign to influence the GTA 6 Metacritic user rating is a proliferation of 0 scores. Some entries include profanity and don’t discuss gameplay, the story, or graphics. Still, many complaints expressed in the harshest evaluations are performance-related. The visuals stay at 30 fps or under on the PS5 Pro, a limitation the impressive 99 mark may not reflect.

The site can delete submissions consisting of offensive language or spam from the same individuals. Otherwise, the low ratings are likely to survive long after the release date.

Adam Corsetti
Adam Corsetti – Tech Writer – 1761 articles published on Notebookcheck since 2025

I became interested in technology at a young age and enjoyed discovering the latest innovations. While earning college degrees in publishing, I created several PC hardware and gaming websites. My passion has always been to guide readers on what products can truly improve their lives. After many years as a Tech Writer for Game Rant, I’m anxious to share my knowledge with a new audience at Notebookcheck.


Story via Notebookcheck. Read the original article