Rockstar Games

Rockstar Games’ “Grand Theft Auto VI” can’t escape the culture wars it seems as the initial user scores for the title are in at numbers so low that it has sparked talk of review bombing.

Among critics, the game has scored an astonishing 99/100 and is tied for the highest-rated video game of all time. But user scores are currently sitting at just 5.4/10 from 30,031 user ratings at the time of writing.

That’s up from the 4.9/10 the title was pulling in when the first few thousand reviews came in. Still, it has led to talk of the game being review-bombed according to GameRant.

The definition of ‘review bombing’ is of a large number of users deliberately leaving negative reviews for a game, movie, or product to “protest something unrelated to its actual quality”.

A good number of reviews offer legitimate criticism of the overall slower pacing compared to previous entries, along with the switch to a more realistic tone. Quite a few, however, also rely on single-line slogans involving the game being too ‘woke’ and talk of a DEI agenda.

Most often the giveaway for game review bombing on an aggregate site like Metacritic is disproportionate voting. One of the most famous examples is “The Last of Us Part II” with user scores at 5.9 from just under 169,000 User Ratings. That’s a ridiculously high number of votes considering the first racked up just 18,000 User Ratings, while far bigger commercial hits like “Cyberpunk 2077,” “Elden Ring” and “Baldur’s Gate 3” had around 40,000, 25,000 and 22,000 respectively.

But with “Grand Theft Auto VI,” that is much harder to prove due to both the sheer scale of its success as well as a lot of time passing since the fifth entry, which had only 6,217 User Ratings. Arguably the closest comparison is “Red Dead Redemption II,” which took seven years to rack up 39,400 User Ratings – a number GTA6 will likely pass within its first week.

A very good write-up has gone up at Aftermath talking about how this is the first release of the franchise in the age of the ‘Collapsed Information Ecosystem’ where the game is “already drowning in misinformation, out-of-context takes and the compounding effects of siloed internet echo chambers and algorithmic reward systems”.

They add there are many takes out there complaining about things that are either not true, partly true but missing key context, or more often being edited to fit an agenda: “If someone can make a clip that speaks to an agenda, or they can frame a gameplay system in a way that generates clicks or views, then they’ll do it the same way your lungs will draw air.”

Despite the backlash, developer Rockstar Games and publisher Take-Two Interactive are hardly struggling. The game has just had the biggest entertainment launch of all time, making $3.79 billion dollars in one day and is already into the top 30 best-selling games of all time.


Story via Darkhorizons. Read the original article