For the past few years, we’ve seen a kind of renaissance in mobile-exclusive RPGs, transforming them into substantial, standalone experiences. Games like last year’s Octopath Traveler 0 and last month’s Final Fantasy Resonance proved that dodgy gacha titles didn’t have to die on the mobile vine. Instead, they could be triumphantly salvaged as some of their respective franchise’s greatest entries in years.

Wright Flyer Studios’ Another Eden Begins is the latest example of a mobile JRPG given the standalone treatment. Unfortunately, it falls well short of that high standard.

A Matt Berry-sounding frog samurai is the quickest way to my heart.

When I wrapped up my impressions of the demo, I came away both impressed and underwhelmed, mentioning that I wouldn’t mind jumping back in for another 20 hours to see it through to the end. Well, I got those 20 hours that I asked for, but I never made it to the end. After roughly 25 hours in total, I dropped the game. I was probably pretty close to the finish line too, but I just couldn’t muster the willpower to get there, which makes this the only game I’ve ever reviewed that I didn’t reach credits on. The reason is simple: it was painfully dull, to the point that it literally put me to sleep on multiple occasions. Nearly every issue I had with the demo snowballed over a long stretch, and the things I liked weren’t enough to offset them.

The time-traveling adventure of Aldo, Feinne, and the friends they meet along the way is so tropey and shallow that not even the frog samurai, Cyrus, could save it from mediocrity (though I did enjoy his posh, Matt Berry-sounding voiceover). The setup I poked fun at in the demo, complete with an obligatory village festival and a special boy with a destiny, turned out to be a pretty accurate preview of what was to come. The game is obviously reminiscent of Chrono Trigger, but only on the surface, and it never reaches even a fraction of that game’s charm. The story occasionally treads into somewhat interesting territory, and I’m usually a sucker for anything time travel-related, but it keeps falling back on all-too-familiar tropes.

This section was eerily reminiscent of the Mako Reactor scene from Final Fantasy VII. It’s a nice homage if nothing else.

Where the game really lost me was in its sprawling roster. There are an overwhelming number of characters to unlock, each with a sidequest line you can complete to raise your “kinship” with them. Kinship levels also go up by using certain party members in battle, but it was never clear to me what difference they actually make. Once you gain access to more than four characters, everyone else goes into a reserve team that you can swap to in the middle of a battle, yet kinship levels seemed to keep climbing even for characters that weren’t in my current party, which made me wonder what the point of the mechanic was in the first place.

That sprawl is undoubtedly a symptom of the game’s gacha roots, but since most of these characters aren’t woven into the main story, their storylines and sidequests feel completely superfluous. They’re easily the weakest part of the game, closer to glorified one-off visual novels with some gameplay sprinkled in than compelling narrative threads that add to the whole. I did them for nearly every party member over the first 10 or so hours, then stopped altogether once they started to feel more like a waste of time than anything else.

The combat has its fun moments, but this is a very easy game that rarely, if ever, challenged me. In the demo, I figured the difficulty would balance out further into the game. It didn’t. I saw only one “game over” screen in my couple of dozen hours, and it was nothing a quick party readjustment couldn’t fix. I see this as both a positive and a negative. On one hand, the story always moved forward with minimal pain points. On the other, the lack of challenge meant I rarely had to think hard about party composition or battle strategy. I could steamroll every basic enemy without ever needing to grind for levels or better gear.

Regular battles in the overworld rarely pose a challenge, but they flow fast enough that they’re not a chore.

I’m not saying this as a humble brag either. Pretty early on, you unlock the “Another Force” gauge, which fills bit by bit after every attack. Once it’s at least half full, you can unleash a barrage of special abilities from each party member as many times as you can press the corresponding face buttons before the gauge depletes and needs to be recharged through normal combat. If battles weren’t easy already, this mechanic absolutely melts bosses and trivializes what should be epic showdowns. It almost feels like you’re playing with cheats enabled, but no, this is a core part of the combat loop that Another Eden Begins consistently encourages you to use.

Chain attacks, which I also mentioned in my impressions, are just as easy to pull off and result in powerful combos that rarely require much thought. Each character has a different requirement for filling their chain meter, such as regular attacks for Riica, critical hits for Amy, and exploiting an enemy’s weakness for Aldo, but almost all of these conditions are met naturally over the course of a battle, so you hardly ever have to plan around them. I did like how fluid and fast this system makes combat, and watching your party perform a flurry of moves one after the other is satisfying in the same way knocking over dominoes is. But it also makes normal encounters such a cakewalk that battles border on brainless. Toward the end of my time with the game, it mostly felt like I was just going through the motions. I’m at least thankful there are no random battles, that you can avoid nearly every basic encounter if you don’t feel like fighting, and that you can double battle speed, which is a nice quality-of-life feature.

Finding and collecting cats in towns and the overworld is strangely a major (optional) part of this game that I actually found quite charming.

I also mentioned this in my demo impressions, but I can’t get over how much I dislike the art style of the characters on screen. I know this isn’t the biggest-budget game, but the chibi aesthetic looks so cheap, especially next to the beautiful backgrounds and tantalizing character portraits that show up in menus and dialogue boxes. Not a fair comparison, I know, but it’s a tough pill to swallow when put up against the gorgeous HD-2D pixel art of Final Fantasy Resonance, for example.

If I had to pick one word to describe Another Eden Begins, it would be “bland.” Bland, archetypal characters, combat that practically plays itself, and mind-numbingly dull sidequests made this a slog to push through. I know this review sounds harsh, but I truly couldn’t play for more than two hours at a time without my eyes getting heavy and my head starting to nod. It’s far from the worst game I’ve ever played, but it is boring, and that’s the hardest thing for me to forgive.

To be perfectly clear, Another Eden Begins is not a bad game. Combat can be fluid and fun, it runs flawlessly on PC and Switch 2, and I experienced no crashes or technical issues whatsoever. But in the sea of incredible RPGs we find ourselves in right now, it’s exceedingly hard to recommend one that’s just fine.



Story via Smashpad. Read the original article