Monster collecting and farming are at the intersection of coziness in gaming for a lot of people. There’s something about both genres that lend themselves to feeling like the type of game you want to play after a long hard day and you just need to relax. What if instead of choosing one or the other you can get both? That’s the core idea of Ova Magica.

Ova Magica starts off like any other farming game – you move to a town to take over your mother’s old farm. You then get to meet the characters around town, build up your farm, and grow crops. However, the new twist is that this town also has a tournament for fighting blobs, monsters that can both battle and, depending on which one you raise, help with farm tasks or produce goods for your farm outright. So your blob cow might be able to fight AND be milked.

One of the systems I think is coolest with Ova Magica is that there is what seems to be a fairly robust monster breeding system in this game. Once you have a barn and multiple blobs, you can have two of them breed to create hybrid blobs that have different traits from each parent. They will also look like a mix of each blob. I can see this being kind of an addicting system, especially if you want to go deep into fully optimizing your team of blobs for battling. Blobs also level up their stats by using moves that align with each of the three main stats (attack, defense, speed) so if your blob doesn’t have a move to use for one stat, you really should see if you can breed a better blob. My starter blob, for example, doesn’t have a move to increase speed, so this would likely be something I’d want to do. This is pretty unusual for a monster collecting game but feels like it all makes sense and fits well with the farming game.

My biggest issue, however, is that a lot of the monster collecting and fighting just isn’t very fun. It’s very difficult to find new monsters outside of breeding – after looking it up, apparently you are supposed to have a chance of finding an egg after some battles, but I never found any. And a lot of the fighting is just pretty boring. There is a type system but there are only three major monster types. You can go on expeditions into the blob world but they feel like I’m just constantly fighting the same monsters over and over. And since leveling is based on moves, there are so many battles where it feels like I’m not making much progress at all, even if I’m fighting higher level blobs.

I think this is all related to my frustrations with the game. I like a lot of the ideas at play, but Ova Magica rarely comes together to be a cohesive experience that is fun to play. For example, to get to the second tier of the blob fighting tournament, you need to increase your friendship with every one of the 13 characters you can befriend around town. On the one hand, I like that systems are tied together, but on the other hand it feels really arbitrary when there’s no story reason for this to make sense. The characters often feel flat, which makes this obstacle a chore and not something you would come to naturally. You just have to keep talking to these characters repeating the same few lines over and over.

Overall, the repetition and lack of fun are representative of my experience with Ova Magica. There are so many moments where I felt like there was something interesting at play, but then there was never enough story, never enough polish to make it feel worthwhile. This is one of those games I wish I liked a lot more than I do. The character art is charming, but the characters don’t feel much like people. The integration of combat and farming is interesting, but neither system feels particularly special. I think there is something here, but it never ended up being too magical.


Story via Nintendoworldreport. Read the original article