This critic is no stranger to the really old video games, yet the return of the much more recent Icy Tower made him feel extra nostalgic. Is it because the original freeware title arrived during that peculiar sweet spot between his teenage years and adulthood? Was it because it came in the early 2000s, that magical era that’s harder to explain to young folk than showing Excel to a medieval peasant? Who knows.

What all this is trying to say is that this remake of Free Lunch Design’s classic carries an unusually heavy backpack of memories. This forced yours truly to summon the courage to consciously remove his nostalgia goggles and approach this as objectively as possible. Thankfully, and in the words of the game’s hype announcer, this remains an AMAAAZING experience.

Image for Icy Tower Review Screenshots and Art

Johan Peitz and Anders Svensson’s deceptively simple indie gem was originally released in 2001, with its many iterations quickly becoming a familiar fixture on countless PCs at home, before spreading its wings and getting a couple of ports for mobile phones, including a relatively obscure sequel. For anyone who missed earlier releases of it, Icy Tower was a fast-paced, arcadey, vertical platformer in which Harold the Homeboy had to climb the titular endless tower, jumping between platforms while chasing higher floors and increasingly ridiculous scores.

The remake, which was built from the ground up, offers a couple of expected modernisations for something so old, starting with gamepad compatibility. That’s certainly welcome, but nostalgia is a powerful and occasionally unreasonable thing, and as such this was tested with the traditional arrow keys and spacebar scheme, just as the Old Gods demand. Thankfully, the controls remain as responsive and reliable as they always were, a must in a game where a fraction of a second can separate a fantastic leap from an embarrassing tumble.

Image for Icy Tower Review Screenshots and Art

Harold runs from side to side, gradually ascending the tower, platform by platform, with the goal of reaching the highest floor and racking the biggest score possible. The whole thing revolves heavily around stringing together combos by building momentum and executing multi-floor jumps. Precision, quick positioning, split-second reflexes and mastery of wall-bouncing are essential, with the challenge ramping up considerably as time goes on. Platforms become smaller and, more importantly, the tower scrolls downward at an increased pace, leaving little room for error. The whole premise takes seconds to grasp, but mastering it is another matter entirely.

There are no complicated mechanics to learn, only a demanding rhythm that can initially feel impossible to get a hold of, with failure being extremely common. The remake doesn’t sacrifice its old-school approach to difficulty, but it does include a welcome addition in the form of Kickback. This gradually charges while pulling off combo jumps, and effectively acts as an extra life, propelling Harold upwards when he falls. That doesn’t make the game any less nerve-racking. This is still all about trying again, and again, and again, just for a microscopic increase of the score and the pleasure of watching your name creep up the leaderboards from #3000 to #2999.

Image for Icy Tower Review Screenshots and Art

There is always one more opportunity to do slightly better, thus hours disappear with alarming ease. There are, admittedly, a few irritations. The dopamine-sparking, congratulatory messages that appear after reaching a specific combo tier can be distracting, blocking a portion of the screen for a second or two just when visibility matters most. Harold’s speed and jumping power can also change rather abruptly, making it difficult to judge exactly how much momentum he has left. Since everything moves so rapidly, those shifts are sometimes difficult to calculate before it is too late. Doesn’t exactly feel unfair, just irritating.

The remake embraces a chunky, pixel-perfect and colourful retro style. A great change from the older versions is how the once spartan background now features gaps in the walls from which one can see distant vistas. Inevitably something of the original’s peculiar personality has gone missing. Everything looks “better” but the remake cannot quite recreate the rough freeware charm of version 1.1 or the SNES-flavoured appeal of 1.4 and beyond. That, and some of the tower biomes are also somewhat straining on the eyes, like floor 300’s mushroom caverns. Or maybe it’s because of the tears shed from the 100th game over screen. Nuh, it’s the background’s fault!

Image for Icy Tower Review Screenshots and Art

A bizarre omission is that feature of the old Facebook version of Icy Tower, where one could personalise their in-game avatars. At least the character roster is quite, well, RADICAL!!! First there’s a disco-loving representative of the ‘70s back from an older version. Next, a robot where Stephen Hawking’s soul resides, enabling him to spend the afterlife in a vertical platformer while an ‘80s robo-synth tune bops along. For GenZers we have a green-haired, Billie Eilish-looking lass, who, against all expectations, is quite likable.

Picking disco-dude over a robot that may or may not hold within it the essence of a theoretical physicist doesn’t alter the gameplay one bit. This quartet of guys and gals is basically Icy Tower’s way of letting one pick a different music track and set of sound effects. They are all a pleasure to listen to, as each is very distinctive, and add a lot to the quirky, feel-good vibe Icy Tower is certainly going for. Despite the extremely high challenge herein, this was mostly made to feel like a joyous party; a party that just so happens to involve occasionally falling from 300 feet.

Image for Icy Tower Review Screenshots and Art

All in all, this is a great return to a great game. As a 25-year update, however, it is somewhat underwhelming. There’s really nothing that can be described as genuinely substantial new content. Apart from Classic there’s the Daily Challenge mode, which gives players one attempt per day, with randomised, altered conditions, such as slippery floors or low gravity. As for Custom, it lets you adjust those variables the way you see fit. A few more unlockables, additional modes or any form of customisation would have gone a long way towards making this feel like a more substantial revival.

The modes available are nothing more than distractions that are nice for practice, but are also rather pointless since the main attraction remains the same game that swallowed afternoons decades ago. Fortunately, the fun factor of said attraction remains enormously potent. Icy Tower is addictive, immediately readable, and possessed of such a light-hearted mood that even spectacularly plummeting to one’s death can prompt a smile. Anyone comfortable seeing 30 game-over screens in under 10 minutes should feel right at home.

Image for Icy Tower Review Screenshots and Art


Story via Cubed3. Read the original article